The Intolerance Debate.
Hot topic, huh?
With no major scams and big reveals on our plates lately, we're taking and swallowing the leftovers of any sense of judgement we have. This is what we seem to be left with- a statement, an opinion, out of proportion reactions, some more opinions, and bam!- a controversy. And ofcourse, those super sentimental one thousand word essays ( don't expect me to call them 'messages') by disappointed former fans that have been doing the rounds on whatsapp, that begin with "Dear Mr. Aamir Khan, I am sorry to say.." and end like "Forward this to all contacts if you love your country."
Just Wonderful.
'Intolerance' - a negative word, right?
'Tolerance', I say, is just as bad. Why should we 'tolerate' a different God? Why should we 'tolerate' another's beliefs? Why should we 'tolerate' another human being at all?
An annoying person or a dreadfully long movie are things that can be 'tolerated'. But our differences... they are meant to be celebrated.
And with a non vegetarian Tamilian Muslim dad, and a Marathi pure veggie Hindu brahmin mother, I feel I'm more than qualified to make this statement.
In our home, we don't 'tolerate'. We celebrate. Eid and Diwali, I mean. And that in itself is a celebration of our differences and the fact that we can be proud of them, and yet look beyond them.
When a Hindu and a Muslim neighbor go over to each other's place with ' Vaishno devi ka prasaad' and 'Eid ki kheer', it is not tolerance- it is celebration.
When a Bengali agrees to teach his Kannad friend a little Bangla, it is celebration.
When a Bharatnatyam dancer applauds after a Bhangra performance, it is celebration.
'I love my country, and I am proud of its rich and varied heritage.'
...... this line symbolizes not tolerance, but celebration of and peace in our diversity.
Speaking of diversity, it horrifies me to even imagine what the world would be like, if everyone we met had the same religion, caste, skin color, beliefs, preferences and opinions. Actually, there wouldn't really be anything left to have an opinion about.
Your opinion only matters if there are others that contradict it. If you share the exact same thoughts as a billion others, its not an opinion- it is a trend.
Sure, there wouldn't be conflicts and fights and riots and debates and controversies. What would you call such a world?
Peaceful ?
Uhuh.
Monotonous. And not just 'boring' monotony. The kind that the crew of a ship stuck in the breeze-less, still ocean feels. Where people speak only to break the silence of the sea. With just water to look at and stars to count. Just that instead of 'water water everywhere nor any drop to drink', our song would be...
" Opinions, opinions, everywhere,
all our minds did shrink.
Opinions, same ones everywhere,
we're no more compelled to think."
You see why diversity matters?
There would be no opposition to question the government; they're all on the same side.
Mr Goswami would simply be nodding his head after every panelist has made his point- the same point.
Oh, there wouldn't be any democracy to begin with; the very essence of democracy lies in differences.
There would be no 'unity in diversity' ...
There would just be 'boredom in monotony'.
It is time we let go of this unnecessarily overused word 'tolerance'.
It is time we not just accept, but celebrate and be proud of our differences.
It is time we turn the ' Intolerance Debate' into ' Why Cant We Celebrate?'
"Where the clear stream of reason has not lost its way
- Where The Mind Is Without Fear,
Rabindranath Tagore
Hot topic, huh?
With no major scams and big reveals on our plates lately, we're taking and swallowing the leftovers of any sense of judgement we have. This is what we seem to be left with- a statement, an opinion, out of proportion reactions, some more opinions, and bam!- a controversy. And ofcourse, those super sentimental one thousand word essays ( don't expect me to call them 'messages') by disappointed former fans that have been doing the rounds on whatsapp, that begin with "Dear Mr. Aamir Khan, I am sorry to say.." and end like "Forward this to all contacts if you love your country."
Just Wonderful.
'Intolerance' - a negative word, right?
'Tolerance', I say, is just as bad. Why should we 'tolerate' a different God? Why should we 'tolerate' another's beliefs? Why should we 'tolerate' another human being at all?
An annoying person or a dreadfully long movie are things that can be 'tolerated'. But our differences... they are meant to be celebrated.
And with a non vegetarian Tamilian Muslim dad, and a Marathi pure veggie Hindu brahmin mother, I feel I'm more than qualified to make this statement.
In our home, we don't 'tolerate'. We celebrate. Eid and Diwali, I mean. And that in itself is a celebration of our differences and the fact that we can be proud of them, and yet look beyond them.
When a Hindu and a Muslim neighbor go over to each other's place with ' Vaishno devi ka prasaad' and 'Eid ki kheer', it is not tolerance- it is celebration.
When a Bengali agrees to teach his Kannad friend a little Bangla, it is celebration.
When a Bharatnatyam dancer applauds after a Bhangra performance, it is celebration.
'I love my country, and I am proud of its rich and varied heritage.'
...... this line symbolizes not tolerance, but celebration of and peace in our diversity.
Speaking of diversity, it horrifies me to even imagine what the world would be like, if everyone we met had the same religion, caste, skin color, beliefs, preferences and opinions. Actually, there wouldn't really be anything left to have an opinion about.
Your opinion only matters if there are others that contradict it. If you share the exact same thoughts as a billion others, its not an opinion- it is a trend.
Sure, there wouldn't be conflicts and fights and riots and debates and controversies. What would you call such a world?
Peaceful ?
Uhuh.
Monotonous. And not just 'boring' monotony. The kind that the crew of a ship stuck in the breeze-less, still ocean feels. Where people speak only to break the silence of the sea. With just water to look at and stars to count. Just that instead of 'water water everywhere nor any drop to drink', our song would be...
" Opinions, opinions, everywhere,
all our minds did shrink.
Opinions, same ones everywhere,
we're no more compelled to think."
You see why diversity matters?
There would be no opposition to question the government; they're all on the same side.
Mr Goswami would simply be nodding his head after every panelist has made his point- the same point.
Oh, there wouldn't be any democracy to begin with; the very essence of democracy lies in differences.
There would be no 'unity in diversity' ...
There would just be 'boredom in monotony'.
It is time we let go of this unnecessarily overused word 'tolerance'.
It is time we not just accept, but celebrate and be proud of our differences.
It is time we turn the ' Intolerance Debate' into ' Why Cant We Celebrate?'
"Where the clear stream of reason has not lost its way
into the dreary desert sand of dead habit.....
...into that heaven of freedom, my father, let my country awake."
Rabindranath Tagore
Beautifully expressed Shreeya, I am sure many of us think of all this but to put it down so articulately needs a special pen. Keep it going. I have struggled recently to affirm with UNITY IN DIVERSITY , started sounding like a cliche these days. You brought it back to me. Thanks.
ReplyDeleteGreat message in strong words from a 15 year old girl. Truly expressing the the intolerance in the common man''s mind about the dirty GE played by politicians to divide people for their benefits.
ReplyDeleteAll the best.
Great message in strong words from a 15 year old girl. Truly expressing the the intolerance in the common man''s mind about the dirty GE played by politicians to divide people for their benefits.
ReplyDeleteAll the best.
Exceedingly well written Shreeya !! You are gifted. Keep using it for the good like you are doing now, always. God bless !!
ReplyDeleteExceedingly well written Shreeya !! You are gifted. Keep using it for the good like you are doing now, always. God bless !!
ReplyDeleteVery well articulated. We are one of the most Tolerant nations, at times going to absurd levels. Irrespective of religion, caste etc, law should be enforced on al
ReplyDeleteMind blowing poem shraya..its wake up call to all of us.
ReplyDeleteJai Hind. Jai Bharat
Mind blowing poem shraya..its wake up call to all of us.
ReplyDeleteJai Hind. Jai Bharat
Thoughtful outcome of a pure mind which perhaps refuses to get corrected by few mindless pshychologicaly handicapped human being. Hope people fighting and debating unnecessarily on this topic has the capability to learn more about the same from a 15 years old. A Great upbringing can only Make our new generation to think rationally and see both sides of the coin. Perhaps time to go for compulsory military service in India now. Shreya you are the pride of us and the inspiration for your generation.
ReplyDeleteThoughtful outcome of a pure mind which perhaps refuses to get corrected by few mindless pshychologicaly handicapped human being. Hope people fighting and debating unnecessarily on this topic has the capability to learn more about the same from a 15 years old. A Great upbringing can only Make our new generation to think rationally and see both sides of the coin. Perhaps time to go for compulsory military service in India now. Shreya you are the pride of us and the inspiration for your generation.
ReplyDeleteTruly expressing the the intolerance in the common man''s mind. Beautifully Expressed Shreya keep it up God bless you Best wishes and luck Ahead
ReplyDeleteShreeya, wish a day would come when the world thinks like you.. Celebrate life!!
ReplyDeleteBeautiful thoughts, nicely expressed...
ReplyDeleteShamsher ji and Shilpa ji, You have every reason to celebrate the pride. It is result of great upbringing and not tweaking the innocence.
Keep it up Shreeya.
Thanks-Sanjay Rajora
Good one shreeya!
ReplyDeleteI didn't know all these years you had such a prolific writer inside you..you are a true reflection of Shah sir's in-depth knowledge and Shilpa ma'am's liberalism..kudos!!
Looking forward to many more "aces" from your court..
God bless :-)
Great to read an young mind wonderfully articulating and promoting celebration of diversity which is the most valuable foundation of this civilization. We need many more such kind to bring positivity into the negativity filled literary circuit. Best wishes to shreeya.
ReplyDelete- nandakumar
Hi Shreeya Beti…..Congratulations! I do agree this is the time for celebration. Who can understand better about a Hindu Brahmin girl getting married to a South Indian Muslim boy than me, being the classmate of your dad and the best friend of your mom. I still remember the day when your dad called me from Dalhousie and said look there is a happy news for you, speak to Shilpa, whom I am planning to get married. I was delighted after speaking to your mom, then asked your dad, she sounds Hindu girl. He instantly told me YES and he didn’t stop there, he then ordered me to convince his orthodox parents staying at Avadi. That’s how Nagpur and Avadi joined together and now we are celebrating their daughter making them feel proud. Do not stop expressing your thoughts….you have living examples at home.
ReplyDeleteWhile reading I found some very strong words which conveys lot of meaning like….Tolerance, Intolerance, Celebration, Diversity, Monotony, Opinion, Trend, Peaceful……. and also few lines….”All our minds did shrink….we’re no more compelled to think”. Great thought Shreeya….long way to go…keep rocking beti.
God Bless You!!!
Israel Uncle
Every word of ur reflects the innocence of thots u carry.
ReplyDeleteKeep blogging such pure and good thots.
Every word of ur reflects the innocence of thots u carry.
ReplyDeleteKeep blogging such pure and good thots.
Hi dear. Your thoughts are wonderful. I wish this reach out to the whole world. Let it bring peace. Best wishes. Keep writing. Jai Hind
ReplyDeleteKuddos Shreya...nicely thought and written...keep writing and sharing. I hope people of this country have better mindset and stop creating unnecessary controversies.. God bless you and keep writing more...
ReplyDeleteDear shreeya great thoughts and nicely brought out.Yes true why should we tolerate rather than celebrate.. Good article, it should reach the last person who is speaking about intolerance.. Let your mind speak always...I am also proud that my pal's daughter is so talented.. God bless.. Jai hind & Jai Bharat
ReplyDeleteDear shreeya great thoughts and nicely brought out.Yes true why should we tolerate rather than celebrate.. Good article, it should reach the last person who is speaking about intolerance.. Let your mind speak always...I am also proud that my pal's daughter is so talented.. God bless.. Jai hind & Jai Bharat
ReplyDeleteHi shreeya beti,nice thoughts sculpted by you with tolerance and now we all are celebrating. God bless u.
ReplyDeleteWishing to see more blogs in future.
Loving KG ,Rekha,Harshika& Rithika
Hi shreeya beti,nice thoughts sculpted by you with tolerance and now we all are celebrating. God bless u.
ReplyDeleteWishing to see more blogs in future.
Loving KG ,Rekha,Harshika& Rithika
A powerful message from a 15 year old....hats off to you dear Shreeya (Shenaz)...I wish you could change the rotten mindset of many...May God Bless you dear....Keep blogging...����
ReplyDeleteBetu – Very well thought & powerfully articulated. Many Congrats Betu. Very Proud of you.
ReplyDeleteWow – What a seasoned essayist you have evolved into being amid 2 different poled parents, most tolerated amongst, yet congregating into celebrating a diamond in you.
Yes, Tolerance or Intolerance – does not give any sense of happiness & contentment. So let’s call it “CELEBRANCE”.
“To you be your religion, to me be mine”.
“They who give have all things, they who withhold have nothing”
Be an ever shining Star Betu!!
God Bless,
Chachu.
Amazing articulation betu. As you rightly put it, the recent debates on tv and essays (nope not messages) floating around social media is now getting a tad monotonous. I believe this will pass soon and some other issue gets trending. A vast majority among us would continue to celebrate all things uncommon to ones own self. This belief reinforces because of amazing people like you. Credit goes to Shah and Shilpa for having moulded you into what you are. And there is this pride in me when I say that I know you. Keep blogging your thoughts. Its refreshing to read. NVS
ReplyDeleteDear Darling,
ReplyDeleteCongrats!
Your wide and deep thoughts with highly cultured approach on universality in and around life, it’s ups and downs with intolerance in this material world .
It made me to think what a wonderful soul, we have in you, at this tender age. Thanks to The Almighty, who has bestowed so much blessings on our multilingual matured family.
I pray for worldly pleasures & prosperity to abound your long and cherished life with all boundless fragrances.
With Duwa!
Daadu (Dawood),
Brilliant mind at work!!! This clearly proves your excellence in comprehending all varied facets of an important issue and your confidence in expressing your clear thoughts. Keep on writing & more importantly keep your mind churning to produce more masterpieces!!!
ReplyDeleteShardul
Very well written Shreeya!��
ReplyDeleteShreeya, its awesome, especially for a 15-year-old to think so much in depth. If at all our big and learned people started celebrating life, then there will not be any such issues as intolerance. Shreeya, I wish that this write up be an eye-opener for all, specially for those who really require one.
ReplyDelete---Marykutty Mathew
Great thoughts and very well expressed shreeya... M really happy to witness this time of change and transition of Indian generation who is above religion, cast and colour.... Itz high time we start celebrating humanity in every sense....
ReplyDeleteDear Shreeya!!
ReplyDeleteKudos to your positive attitude towards life! Very well expressed. Keep it up. Debate, struggle, differences- is part of everybody's life, weather it be your personal life, work life etc... The best is to realize "how to CELEBRATE!". This word can turn a lot of things. Good luck beta!
Great writing Shreeya Beti! True, I totally agree with you. We are proud of your Mom - my dear elder sister Shilpa and of course you and Jijaji!!! Stay blessed as always and keep writing!
ReplyDeleteSundar ... This is what we who have lived half our lifetime expect from young Indians; 'Celebrate'the differences. Well said..
ReplyDeleteDear Shreeya, Shipa and Shahji, I read everything which I come across on such topics. But your views are supreme, pure to the core and felt by the majority of the people who prefer to remain silent. You have shown the right path of thinking. It is the attitude which matters in life. Such a wonderful attitude at such a tender age of 15 years is rare to see. We were very proud of Shilpa from the day she joined the elite force, but now we take more pride to see such a well knit family and a wonderful daughter like you.
ReplyDeleteI wish you a very bright future and best wishes to your parents. Shekhar Urhekar
Dear Shreeya,
ReplyDeleteVery nice thoughts. Brilliantly written!! I loved it.
Best Regards,
Manoj
Oh My God...thank you so much for all the kind words, everyone. I am glad, and very surprised, that so many adults agree with me; I didn't expect this! Thank you for taking the time to read and share your views. It means a lot to me.
ReplyDeleteSo motivating :)
Regards and Gratitude,
Shreeya..
What an excellent article Shenaz/Shreeya!! I just loved it. You have penned down your thoughts on one of the most talked about topics of present times so beautifully at such a young age, that it is commendable.Our little angel has a great talent. Looking forward for your next masterpiece. Continue to amaze us with your writings dear.
ReplyDeleteAll the best!!
Love,
Chachi
Shreeya, words fail me. I am proud, relieved and thankful to see such mature, forward-looking thoughts from you. If others of your generation think the same way, India will be in good hands down the road. I am proud to see your writing. Such cogency, thought organization and presentation-I was floored and had to reread it three times before going thoroughly speechless. I loved your statement that "tolerance is just as bad". Tolerance has such a negative connotation, does it not? It seems to imply that tolerant people tolerate because they do not have a choice. Is letting things be "tolerant"? I think not. So your conversion of tolerance into celebration is a masterstroke. Because that is what it is. Finally, your ending with "where the mind is without fear" -just genius. It is one of my top 5 all-time favorites. With a little work, you could send this piece to be published. Salute to you!
ReplyDeleteWords can leave one speechless. There is nothing left for me to say here Shreeya. Fantastic flow of thoughts that are so effortlessly channelised. I see my own shades in you. For a young mind to deliver so brilliantly, it is an honour for me to show up here. Differences are meant to be celebrated. Absolutely..the so called intelligent ones don't. Hey..I think I just said you left me speechless..but the inspiration worked ..:-)
ReplyDeleteWooow wat a wonderful and thoughtful blog shreeya.....tolerance and celebration....grt way to luk at thngs....u r truly an inspiration to so many young ppl out there...grt...keep it up...luking forward for many more writings from you
ReplyDeleteWith lots of love,
Anujin
Nice & inspiring thoughts from an young girl.. Ur zeal to not make a change, but be the change looks obvious from ur thoughts & the way of expressing them is appreciable. Ur a wonderful gift to ur parents & already making them proud.
ReplyDeleteWishing you all luck, success & happiness in the coming days.. Happy b'day dear Shreeya..
Shreeya you really expressed the topic excellently.... Keep writing . Daksh (your Bhai)
ReplyDeleteMight I say u set flares on my calm indifference to something as mere as tolerance. You write amazingly. You have lot to give to this society!
ReplyDeleteMight I say u set flares on my calm indifference to something as mere as tolerance. You write amazingly. You have lot to give to this society!
ReplyDeleteWell written I must say, CELEBRATION that was the key here xD
ReplyDelete